Dear Mr. Lucas,
I would like to begin by thanking you for the phenom that is Star Wars. Your story has brought much joy to my life and has spanned the short three deacades that I have been alive. I, along with countless others, have been happy to pump millions of dollars into your franchise if even to just be a remote part of “galaxy far far away” of which we love so much.
(sigh) After watching the 3rd and last installment of the prequels I have the feeling of reserved satisfaction. It is the same feeling you get when you find yourself craving a Big Mac combo only to have satisfied that craving and finding yourself feeling like you have just ate 3 pounds of wet sand. You aren’t hungry anymore, but are quite that sure what you ate wasn’t what you wanted.
Why do you insist on writing and directing when you are the most brilliant producer ever? Is it a control thing? Because if it is, we can pinpoint that as to why this set of features have been disappointing. Didn’t we learn this from the original trilogy?
I guess I am simply frustrated.
Why the cheesy dialogue? Admittedly, this one was far better than the first 2. However, it didn’t take much to achieve that. It is not as if the offending lines couldn’t be rewritten easily to be a little more intelligent. Actors like Portman, Christensen, and especially McGregor are not terrible actors, but come off as such in these films when they talk. After the outcry from the last two films I thought more attention would be paid to the script. I was disappointed.
The action sequences were awesome. Lightsabre battles, starfighter duels…great. I miss the “real” sets. And “real” actors. Over the top with the CGI, but we have come to expect this with these movies. It was good, but part of the magic of the originals was the “realness” of it all. Costumes, sets, and makeup create a dimension that computer graphics don’t. At least not yet. Don’t get me wrong, they are impressive in their own right… I just miss some of the things that made Star Wars so amazing. Perhaps you should take a line from your own movie… “Don’t be too proud of this technological terror you’ve constructed.” Just a thought.
And lastly the anti-climactic climax. Why (in all 3) do we have these amazing battles (which is what we want to see…huge lightsabre duels, acrobatics, the darke side etc.) that end with a technicality? It’s like we stop the action. Declare that the end is near. And then we end it. Why not have someone lose in the fury? Why have the fury and build it up…and then let the bottom fall out? To top it off it is prefaced with a bad line. A great end scene marred by bad scripting and a poor jump.
Believe it or not I did enjoy your movie. I just expected more. When I uncontrollably cringe everytime the duo of Padme/Skywalker are on screen… (sigh). I wanted to like this movie more than I did. Maybe that’s the problem. It just seems like you decided to abandon the old school fans in search for a new crowd and that hurts.
Still Your Fan,
Caleb
***Anybody feel different than this? I sound harsh… but I did enjoy the movie, but I just wonder if it was not because of the phenom itself and not necessarily this movie. It’s hard to separate the individual movie from the Saga.***